Why Can’t We Talk about Amanda’s Mom Investigative

Hosted By: Sarah Cailean

On November 15, 1993, the body of a woman was discovered on a dirt road near Interstate-10 in Mobile, Alabama. She was nude, drained of blood, and decapitated. The victim was identified as Renée Bergeron, the mother of a young girl named Amanda. Despite the horrific nature of the murder, it received little attention in the press, and the detectives assigned to the case failed to make an arrest.

Over two decades later, investigative journalist Sarah Cailean decided to reopen the case. In her podcast, Why Can’t We Talk about Amanda’s Mom?, Cailean recounts her three-year investigation, which led her to uncover a web of secrets and lies. She interviews Renée’s family and friends, as well as the detectives who worked the case. She also explores the possibility that Renée’s murder was connected to a serial killer who was operating in the area at the time.

Why Can’t We Talk about Amanda’s Mom Podcast Host:

Sarah Cailean is an investigative journalist and the host of the podcast Why Can’t We Talk about Amanda’s Mom?. She has written for publications such as Rolling Stone, The New York Times, and The Washington Post. Cailean is passionate about telling the stories of victims of crime and bringing justice to their families.

Praise from Listeners*:

  • Empathetic Approach: Sarah Cailean’s investigation is meticulous and compassionate, showing sensitivity to Renée’s family and friends, who are still grieving her loss.
  • Engaging Interviews: Cailean’s interviews with Renée’s family and friends are moving and intimate. They provide listeners with a better understanding of who Renée was as a person and the impact her murder had on her loved ones.

Criticisms from Listeners*:

  • Pacing: The podcast is slow-paced and can be repetitive at times. Some listeners have complained that the podcast drags on too long and that Cailean rehashes the same information over and over again.
  • Lack of Closure: The podcast does not provide any new solutions to the case. While Cailean does uncover some new evidence and interviews new suspects, she is ultimately unable to solve Renée’s murder. This can be frustrating for listeners who are hoping for closure.

* The True Crime Connection teams aims to keep this as an unbiased search database. In order to do this, we curate what people love the most and the least about a podcast by analysing ApplePodcast reviews.

To hear about our personal favorites/feedback, check out our Instagram or TikTok.
To submit a change to this listing, click here.

Want to leave your own review for fellow true crime fans to find when they hit this page? Add it in the comments below!


Add Review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Both show and individual episode descriptions for listings on the TCC website have been submitted directly from the podcast featured or found online. We do our best to make sure all information is accurate, however; if there are any corrections to be made, please let us know here.