Small Town Murder Comedy/Casual

Hosted By: James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman

Small Town Murder is a true crime comedy podcast hosted by comedians James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman. Each episode, they examine a murder that took place in a small town, providing in-depth research and their own comedic spin on the events.

Small Town Murder Podcast Host:

James Pietragallo is a stand up comedian and filmmaker. He co-hosts Crime In Sports, Small Town Murder and PS I Hate This Movie podcasts.

Jimmie Whisman is an American Comedian and a podcaster currently working as the co-host both in Small Town Murder and Crime In Sports.

Praise from Listeners*:

  • Balanced Humor: The hosts skillfully inject humor into their discussions, striking a delicate balance between levity and respect for the victims. The comedic interludes offer much-needed relief while never detracting from the gravity of the crimes.
  • Unique Format: Small Town Murder offers a distinctive format that sets it apart from other true crime podcasts. The hosts delve deep into the history and context of each town, providing a comprehensive understanding of the setting in which the crimes occurred.
  • Engaging Chemistry: James and Jimmie’s friendship and camaraderie shine through in their banter and interactions. Their chemistry creates a welcoming and comfortable atmosphere that keeps listeners coming back for more.
  • Empathy for Victims: The hosts approach each case with empathy and compassion for the victims and their families. They emphasize the human element, ensuring that the stories are not reduced to mere statistics but rather a reminder of the lives lost.
  • Longevity and Consistency: With a vast catalog of episodes, Small Town Murder has established a reputation for consistency and longevity. Listeners appreciate the reliability and the ability to binge-listen to a wide range of cases.

Criticisms from Listeners*:

  • Lengthy Episodes: Some listeners find the podcast’s episodes to be too long. This length can occasionally lead to a sense of pacing issues or a feeling of the podcast being drawn out.
  • Excessive Tangents: James and Jimmie are known for their engaging banter and humorous tangents. However, some listeners feel that these tangents can at times veer off course and distract from the main narrative, making the episodes feel less focused.
  • Sensationalism: A small subset of listeners has criticized the podcast for occasionally using sensational language or humor in discussing serious crimes. While the hosts aim to balance humor and respect, some listeners feel that the comedic elements can occasionally trivialize the seriousness of the crimes being discussed.

* The True Crime Connection teams aims to keep this as an unbiased search database. In order to do this, we curate what people love the most and the least about a podcast by analysing ApplePodcast reviews.

To hear about our personal favorites/feedback, check out our Instagram or TikTok.
To submit a change to this listing, click here.

Want to leave your own review for fellow true crime fans to find when they hit this page? Add it in the comments below!


Add Review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Both show and individual episode descriptions for listings on the TCC website have been submitted directly from the podcast featured or found online. We do our best to make sure all information is accurate, however; if there are any corrections to be made, please let us know here.